Event Information

Venue(s):
St. Patrick's Cathedral (Mott Street)

Conductor(s):
Gustavus Schmitz [organist/composer]
Henry Schmitz [French horn]

Event Type:
Choral

Record Information

Status:
Published

Last Updated:
25 April 2025

Performance Date(s) and Time(s)

25 Dec 1873, 10:30 AM

Program Details

There is some confusion in the citations over who performed Proch’s “Ecce panis,” although it was definitely sung by a soprano with horn obligato. The most likely situation is that provided in the New York Sun review: Mrs. Grosz sang and Henry Schmitz played horn. Henry Schmitz was the French hornist of the Thomas Orchestra and led the 3:30pm Mass at St. Patrick’s Cathedral later that afternoon (see separate event entry); he seems to have been something of a special guest.

Performers and/or Works Performed

2)
aka O come all ye faithful
Composer(s): Wade
3)
Composer(s): Lambillotte
5)
Composer(s): Schmitz [organist/composer]
6)
Composer(s): Rossini
7)
aka Imperial Mass; Mass, no. 3; Nelson Mass
Composer(s): Haydn

Citations

1)
Announcement: New York Sun, 24 December 1873, 1.

“There will be masses every hour during the forenoon; at half-past 10 a grand Pontifical High Mass, at which the music will be Haydn’s beautiful Third Mass in D.”

2)
Announcement: New-York Daily Tribune, 25 December 1873, 5.
3)
Announcement: New-York Times, 25 December 1873, 8.

“At the offertory, the organist will play a solo on the French horn.” (The New York Times review of 12/26/73 states that a “Mr. Groz” performed this solo; the New York Sun review of the same day claims that it was Heindrich Schmitz.)

4)
Announcement: New York Herald, 25 December 1873, 6.

The unidentified work by Schmitz is “a new work.”

5)
Review: New York Sun, 26 December 1873, 1.

“In addition to the elaborate music of Haydn’s Third Mass was an Adeste Fidelis sung to a simple old melody, the alternate verses in solo and chorus. The offertory song was Ecce Panis by Proch, sung by an accomplished amateur, Mrs. Grosz, sister of the Schmitzes, with French horn obligato, played by her brother Heindrich, beautiful in both itself and in its perfect execution.”

6)
Review: New-York Daily Tribune, 26 December 1873, 5.

“…The musical services were conducted by Gustavus Schmitz and Haydn’s ‘Third Mass in D’ was rendered.” No further mention of music.

7)
Review: New-York Times, 26 December 1873, 8.

“…The music selected for the occasion was Haydn’s beautiful third mass in D under the direction of the organist, Prof. Gustavus Schmitz. The choir was assisted by a powerful chorus from the Philharmonic Society. The solo singers were [lists singers] and Henry [sic] Schmitz, conductor. At the elevation ‘Ecce Panis,’ soprano solo was given with French-horn accompaniment by Mr. Groz. The ‘Agnus Dei’ was rendered by Miss Ballard, alto solo; and just preceding the sermon ‘Veni Creator’ as a solo soprano was sung by Miss J. Sullivan.”