Christine Nilsson Concert: 10th

Event Information

Venue(s):
Steinway Hall

Manager / Director:
Max Strakosch

Conductor(s):
Carlo Ercole Bosoni

Price: $2; $3 and $4, reserved

Event Type:
Opera

Performance Forces:
Vocal

Record Information

Status:
Published

Last Updated:
14 June 2023

Performance Date(s) and Time(s)

24 Oct 1870, 8:00 PM

Program Details

American debut of pianist Marie Krebs.



Nilsson attended Kelly and Leon’s Minstrels on 10/28/70 and laughed at a good-natured imitation sketch of her own singing (see separate event entry).

Performers and/or Works Performed

2)
Composer(s): Auber
4)
aka Ave Maria; Ellens dritter Gesang; Hymne an die Jungfrau; Serenade
Composer(s): Schubert
Text Author: Scott
Participants:  Christine Nilsson
6)
Composer(s): Verdi
Participants:  Pasquale Brignoli
7)
aka Ah, mio figlio; Beggar's song; Prophete. Ah! mons fils
Composer(s): Meyerbeer
Participants:  Annie Louise Cary
8)
Composer(s): Bellini
Participants:  Christine Nilsson
10)
Composer(s): Cohen
Participants:  Christine Nilsson
11)
Composer(s): Verdi
13)
aka Perpetual motion; Moto continuo
Composer(s): Weber
Participants:  Marie Krebs
14)
Composer(s): Vieuxtemps
Participants:  Henri Vieuxtemps
15)
aka March; Fest march; Festmarsch; Grand march; Tannhauser. Freudig begrussen wir die edle Halle. Allegro
Composer(s): Wagner

Citations

1)
Advertisement: New-York Times, 13 October 1870, 7.
2)
Announcement: New York Sun, 21 October 1870, 3.

Arrival of pianist Marie Krebs from Germany.

3)
Announcement: New York Post, 22 October 1870, 4.

Arrival of pianist Maria Krebs, with her mother, from Germany.

4)
Announcement: New York Herald, 24 October 1870, 6.
5)
Announcement: New York Herald, 24 October 1870, 8.
6)
Announcement: New York Sun, 24 October 1870, 2.

Valuable addition of Maria Krebs to the company.

7)
Review: New York Herald, 25 October 1870, 7.

“The return of the Swedish nightingale to the metropolis after her triumphs in Philadelphia and Baltimore showed no diminution in the eagerness of the public to hear her. Steinway Hall was fairly crowded last night, and the fair cantatrice was greeted with as much heartfelt enthusiasm as at her debut. The beautiful melody with which Franz Schubert invested the hymn to the Blessed Virgin, ‘Ave Maria,’ came from her lips in all its pristine purity and sweetness, and she responded to the inevitable encore with a coquettish Swedish air of a most peculiar kind. The prayer of the Druidical priestess, ‘Casta Diva,’ was sung by her with exquisite tenderness and expression. The rare purity of intonation, which at times has almost the effect of an echo, and which places Nilsson’s voice entirely apart from all others, made Norma’s prayer a tone poem, warm with religious fervor and thrilling in its tenderness and deep feeling. The novelty of the concert was the first appearance in America of a young German pianist, Mlle. Marie Krebs, who arrived in this country a few days ago. She is very young, very handsome and brings from Europe a high artistic reputation. She made a bold venture last night for a début, playing at first in immediate succession a melody by Rubinstein and Liszt’s arrangement of the well known tarantella ‘Le Muette di Portici.’ The melody is simple and extremely beautiful, and served principally to show the fair pianist’s poetic soul as interpreted by her fingers. We do not like Liszt’s arrangement of the morceau from Auber’s opera, as it is far inferior to that of Thalberg. But it is immensely difficult and a regular Chinese puzzle, and very few pianists can make it even intelligible. Mlle. Krebs conquered it, however, and lighted it up with those touches of color that the true and great artist alone is capable of imparting to a work. For an encore she again made a daring venture. Every pianist knows what a terrible thing the ‘Perpetual Movement’ of Weber is to play in public, and how extremely difficult it is to avoid a faux pas in its rapid and eccentric passages. Mlle. Krebs played it to perfection, and such a test, triumphantly overcome, places her among our leading artists. Her touch is wonderfully sympathetic and emotional, and there is a spontaneity about her style of playing that mere executive ability alone cannot command. Chromatic passages, melodic duets and strange chords flow from her fingers in their entirety with a spirit and expression peculiarly her own. Her touch also, though generally light, gives more idea of power than the pounding of a half dozen demented disciples of the Liszt school. She never strains after effect, but it comes as a natural consequence from her intimate acquaintance with the ideas of the composer. No city in the world is more prolific of pianists than New York, and foreign artists often meet with disappointment here on account of the formidable rivalry they encounter. It is, therefore, a great and signal victory which Marie Krebs has won in at once gaining one of the proudest positions among the crowd of American pianists and making the noble grand on which she played a talisman to the hearts of her auditors. Miss Cary, Brignoli and Verger sang some attractive selections, and a fine orchestra served as an excellent background to these artists. We would recommend, however, Messrs. Brignoli and Verger to leave the comic music of the ‘Barbiere’ to the opera stage, as in concert it is a bore. The next concert takes place on Wednesday. The conductor, Signor Bosoni, proved himself an accomplished artist in his line.”

8)
Review: New York Post, 25 October 1870, 2.
“Miss Nilsson’s return to the city was welcomed at Steinway Hall by a very large and delighted audience last night. The same applause and the often superfluous encores which marked her previous concerts were repeated. The programme was a good one. Miss Nilsson sang Schubert’s serenade, a little French waltz, and the Casta Diva of Bellini, the latter being the most noticeable performance of the evening. The andante was sung with exquisite grace, and revealed thoroughly the charming quality of the Nilsson voice. In the allegro—Ah! bello a me ritorna—there was a facility of execution in everything excepting the chromatic passages, which were slid over rather than sung. Miss Nilsson looked as fascinating as ever, and was most beautifully attired.
Miss Marie Krebs, a very graceful and attractive young lady, who already enjoys a good reputation in Germany and England, made her debut as a pianist at this concert, and was very favorably received. She played a melody by Rubenstein and Liszt’s adaptation of Auber’s ‘Tarantella’ with skill and effect, and was heard with pleasure. Miss Cary, Mr. Vieuxtemps and Signor Brignoli all added their quota to the evening’s enjoyment.”
9)
Review: New-York Times, 25 October 1870, 4.

“Mlle. Nilsson was welcomed with hearty cordiality, last night, on the occasion of her return to New-York. Steinway Hall was crowded by a fashionable audience, and the concert was, in every respect, as satisfactory as the previous ones given by Mlle. Nilsson for her opening series. Mlle. Nilsson looks the picture of health and high spirits, and received the plaudits of the audience with obvious gratification. Her beauty is certainly unimpaired by her provincial tour, and, more important still, the same can be said of her lovely voice. Indeed, practice and travel seem to agree with the songstress, who, happily, has plenty of stamina, so that neither the mellowness of her notes nor the fluency of their delivery appeared to less advantage than when our public first heard them. The programme of last night was ushered in by the overture to ‘Fra Diavolo,’ and this was succeeded by the familiar duet from ‘Il Barbiere,’ sung by Signor Brignoli and M. Verger. The favorite tenor was in fine voice, and the selection was received with pleasure. Mlle. Marie Krebs, a new pianiste, was then heard for the first time in America. Mlle. Krebs played a melody of Rubinstein’s by way of prelude, and followed it with an astonishing piece of execution on a theme from ‘Masaniello.’ We may say at once that the success of the young lady was decided. She has great power, great delicacy and reserve of style, and certainly surprising facility. Of her possession of those higher qualities that go to make up the great pianist, we prefer to speak further after hearing. The performance of this occasion was calculated to exhibit to advantage the merits of brilliancy, execution, and thorough training. The feeling and sentiment that belong to a higher range of art may also be within the grasp of Mlle. Krebs; but of this we have yet to take opportunity to judge. Mlle. Nilsson now sang Schubert’s ‘Ave Maria’ with sweetness and pious grace, and, on the inevitable encore, gave a piquant Swedish song, ending with an osculatory that reminded us of a certain aspiration of Lady Gay Spanker’s, and was accepted with delight by the audience. We may take occasion to observe that, however pleasing at times, the results, the habit of New-York audiences in perpetually insisting on repetitions is neither tasteful nor fair. The artist agrees to give so much and no more. The public imposes on good nature when it demands what it has not paid for. Our concert-goers seem to think they cannot have too much of a good thing—or, sometimes, of a bad one. The habit is under-bred and provincial, and should be reformed altogether. Signor Brignoli sang the romanza from ‘Louisa Miller’ beautifully. His smoothness and finish in this number were almost beyond praise. It was, perhaps, as a consequence of the fact that his effort was not repeated. ‘Ah, mon fils’ was now strongly and pathetically rendered by Miss Annie Louise Cary, who, to our hearing, has also improved since her previous appearance here. The first part was concluded by a noble performance of the ‘Casta Diva,’ in which Mlle. Nilsson fairly aroused enthusiasm. The second part of the programme was, as it should be, more spirited than the first, but it could not well be more finely rendered. Mlle. Nilsson was listened to in two selections, ‘Les Bluets,’ by Cohen, and the soprano allotment in the stirring trio from Verdi’s ‘Attila.’ In the trio Signor Brignoli M. Verger again gave efficient aid. Previous to this M. Vieuxtemps, who was warmly received, played a composition of his own with fine effect. The whole was ended in imposing style by Wagner’s ‘Tannhäuser’ march. Hardly a concert in our memory has passed off, on the whole, with greater smoothness or with greater satisfaction to its hearers.”

10)
Review: New-York Daily Tribune, 25 October 1870, 8.
“The concert given by Mlle. Nilsson last evening did not differ in general character or general excellence from those to which she accustomed us during her previous series. Since her return to this city, a new and valuable member has been added to the company in the person of Mlle. Marie Krebs. This young lady is the daughter of a German composer of some note, known on this side of the Atlantic through his songs. In Germany he has produced operas that have obtained considerable favor.
 
Mlle. Krebs is not yet twenty, but she appeared in public at a very early age, and at Leipsig [sic] and Dresden, and in England she has made a decided mark as a pianist. She played last evening a melody by Rubenstein, Liszt’s arrangement of the Tarantella, and Barcarole from Masaniello, and, being recalled, she gave that movement from Von Weber’s Grand Sonata in C, known as the mouvement perpétuel. These three pieces gave opportunity for Miss Krebs to show her ability in the different essentials to good piano-forte playing. The first required delicacy and poetic sentiment, the second power, and a complete mastery of all the subtle difficulties that the composers of the Liszt school delight to heap together, and which are certain to overwhelm any but the most consummate pianists. The third was a study of facility and legato playing. It was entirely evident that Mlle. Krebs was master, or mistress rather, of the situation, so far as any mere difficulties that might lie in the way are concerned. But it was not quite so clear that she had yet reached the highest point of attainment in expression. In fact, this could hardly be expected in one so young. Expression is the result to experience, of length of years, and of suffering. Mlle. Krebs’ strong points are her astonishing facility and execution, her enthusiasm, and her fine artistic temperament, which is so clearly manifest. If there is a fault, it is that her playing seems somewhat hurried and somewhat too even. There was not a sufficient graduation of touch. Her spirit is young, fresh and buoyant, and it hastens in its course without waiting for these [those?] suspensions and pauses that give such character to the playing of the greatest artists. There is a certain lack of that absolute finish which comes from the training of such teachers as Von Bulow, Dreyschock, Tausig, Rubinstein, Moscheles, and men of that class. In manual dexterity, Mlle. Krebs has nothing to learn, but in those subtle arts, those secrets of the piano-forte, which only the greatest of players and those who have practiced them know how to impart, there is still something left for accomplishment, and her love of her art will doubtless lead her studies in that direction.”
11)
Review: New York Sun, 26 October 1870, 2.
“Miss Nilsson resumed her concerts Monday evening at Steinway Hall. Her selections were excellent, and consisted of pieces not heretofore sung by her. They were Schubert’s ‘Ave Maria,’ a waltz by Cohen, and ‘Casta Diva.’ This last aria has so completely passed away from the concert programmes of late years, as almost to have the effect of a novelty. It has been for a quarter of a century the great test of a singer’s ability. The prima donna who can sing it well can sing anything. Miss Nilsson, it is almost needless to say, belongs to the class of those who can.
 
The concert was made specialty interesting as furnishing the occasion for the début of a new pianist, Miss Marie Krebs. Our concert rooms are already rich in the number of first class piano virtuosi, but Miss Krebs is an invaluable addition in that number. In her, Germany has sent us a performer in whom she takes a special pride, whose brief past has been brilliant, and whose future is full of promise. Miss Krebs is but nineteen, and yet she has left every technical difficulty behind her in her swift progress. She is of the pure Saxon type—tall, slender, and graceful like Nilsson, and like her a blue-eyed blonde. Her refinement of manner and sweetness of expression commended her at once to the sympathies of the audience. She made good the favorable impression by playing with astonishing precision and verve Liszt’s arrangement of some of the airs from ‘Masaniello.’ Into this arrangement the composer has crowded every possible intricacy and difficulty. It is one of the most trying of all his arrangements. Miss Krebs showed in her mastery of it how satisfactory result had been attained by the years of training that she has received.”