Benefit of Victor Maurel

Event Information

Venue(s):
Academy of Music

Manager / Director:
Max Strakosch

Conductor(s):
S. Behrens

Event Type:
Opera

Record Information

Status:

This event is still undergoing additional verification.

Last Updated:
15 April 2025

Performance Date(s) and Time(s)

10 Mar 1874, 8:00 PM

Performers and/or Works Performed

2)
aka Diebische Elster, Die; Thieving magpie
Composer(s): Rossini
3)
Composer(s): Mills
Participants:  Henryk Wieniawski
4)
aka Moro di Venezia, Il
Composer(s): Rossini
Text Author: Berio di Salsa
Participants:  Christine Nilsson
5)
Composer(s): Gounod
Participants:  Christine Nilsson
6)
Composer(s): Levy
Participants:  Henryk Wieniawski
7)
Composer(s): Verdi
8)
aka Blind beggars; Two blind men
Composer(s): Offenbach
Text Author: Moinaux
Participants:  Victor Capoul;  Victor Maurel

Citations

1)
Advertisement: New-York Times, 08 March 1874, 7.

Includes program.

2)
Announcement: New-York Times, 09 March 1874, 4.

“A large audience enjoyed the very varied entertainment arranged for the benefit night of M. Maurel. M. Maurel is one of the most gifted and thorough artists ever listened to in this country, and the tribute paid him by the presence of a numerous gathering yesterday, was but a fitting reward for his labors this season. The part of the performance which pleased us most was the third act of ‘Ernani.’ The pictorial impressiveness of M. Maurel’s Carlo Quinto, the expressiveness and effectiveness of the music allotted to him, and the completeness of the episode brought before the public were the chief points in its favor. To our thinking, the bénéficiare’s singing and acting in ‘Ernani’ are simply perfection, and the third act being the most impressive of the opera, its interest was exceptional. M. Maurel was in fine voice last night, and hence his work was at all points satisfactory. In tender pathos nothing could surpass the opening bars of the air, ‘Oh! de’ verd’ anni miei,’ while the delivery of the lines prefatory to the finale (‘Oh, sommo Carlo’) gave speech within its narrow limits, to the wrath of the offended sovereign, to the struggle between their desire for revenge and a growing sense of the grandeur of clemency, and, at last, to the noble resolve to emulate the virtues of the monarch whose tomb is a solemn reminder of the fleeting character of worldly honors. A spirited recital of Ernani’s music by M. Capoul. (Mlle. Torriani being, as usual, the Elvira), and the co-operation of the well-trained chorus and orchestra, under the bâton of Mr. Behrens, elicited an enthusiastic encore, and, subsequently, the reappearance before the curtain of the principal performers. A brief concert followed, M. Wieniawski playing deliciously his fantasia on ‘Faust’ and his ‘Russian Airs,’ and Mme. Nilsson singing with extreme delicacy of coloring ‘Assisa ai piè d’un salice,’ Rossini’s setting of Shakespeare’s ‘Willow Song,’ and a composition worthy of its theme. Mme. Nilsson had to come forth again after her air, and thereupon she gratefully added to the bill Gounod’s ‘Ave Maria,’ the spirit of which she certainly did not catch, although quite a loud demonstration of delight may be thought to have proved the contrary. During the concert, Signor Scolara, in female attire, figured in an Italian comic scena. The third act of Rigoletto was next, M. Maurel personating Rigoletto and Mlle. Torriani Gilda. The act loses much by separation from the opera, and on this account we cannot form an opinion of what M. Maurel’s complete picture of the jester may be. A master of recitative no less than cantabile, and an actor of intelligence, experience, and unflagging earnestness, his Rigoletto must be possessed of rare merits. As hinted at, however, ex pede Herculem is inapplicable to the present case. Nevertheless the interview with the courtiers was very touching, the contrast of anger and grief in the duet with Gilda very well defined, and the gradations up to ‘Vendetta, tremenda vendetta!’—which passage was declaimed with a concentrated power, the genuineness of which was not to be mistaken—were treated with the nicest art. The representation terminated with ‘Les Deux Aveugles,’ a tiny operette by Offenbach. There is but one step from the sublime to the ridiculous, and that one step, when causing harmless merriment was in view, was almost pardonable and especially on a benefit night, when the house is supposed to be tenanted mainly by the friends of the actors. These words are not superfluous by way of introduction to a record of the fact that M. Capoul acted Giraffler, and M. Maurel, Patachon. Twenty minutes of hearty laughter were the results of the efforts of the two performers. Their ‘make up’ as sham blind men was marvelous, that of M. Capoul being notably elaborate. M. Maurel and his associate were once more summoned before the footlights, and then the assemblage dispersed.”

3)
Review: New-York Daily Tribune, 11 March 1874, 5.

“M. Maurel had a good house for his benefit last night, quite a number of the boxes being occupied and the floor nearly filled. The programme was long and miscellaneous. First came the famous third Act of ‘Ernani,’ in which the popular baritone first made a decided sensation in New-York, and it was given with all due effect, Mlle. Torriani appearing as the heroine and M. Capoul as Ernani. Then followed several concert selections. M. Wieniawski played his ‘Faust’ fantasia and his arrangement of a well-known Russian air. Mme. Nilsson sang the favorite aria from Rossini’s ‘Otello’—‘Assisa al pie d’un salice,’ and for an encore gave the Bach-Gounod ‘Ave Maria,’ M. Wieniawski supplying the violin part, with that admirable accompanist M. Rembielinski at the piano. This was the most charming piece of the evening, except that in the closing passage Mme. Nilsson was betrayed into a bit of bravura singing, which elicited a great deal of applause, though it was not in good taste. Sig. Scolara had a buffo song, disporting himself in female costume; but we cannot conscientiously say that we found it funny. The third act of ‘Rigoletto’ showed M. Maurel at his best, Mlle. Torriani as Gilda giving him competent support; and the long evening closed with Offenbach’s amusing musical farce ‘Les Deux Aveugles,’ in which Capoul and Maurel, as the two blind men, surprised the public by disclosing a vein ot broad humor. This performance was almost perfect of its kind, and kept the house in continual laughter.”

4)
Review: New York Post, 11 March 1874, 2.
“An interesting medley entertainment took place at the Academy of Music last night. It was successful in attracting a fair audience and in affording them much pleasure. The long and varied programme opened with the third act of ‘Ernani’ to bring out Maurel in his great part of ‘Carlos.’ Torriani and Capoul sang the soprano and tenor parts, and the chorus aided vigorously. The result was an immediate encore for the great finale of the act.
A concert ensued. Madame Nilsson sang in her most finished style the great aria from ‘Otello’ and the ‘Ave Maria’ of Bach as arranged by Gounod. Wieniawski played several of his best solos; and an act of ‘Rigoletto’ again brought into full display the magnificent voice and rare dramatic talent of Maurel. 
There was a comic element in this entertainment which, however amusing in itself, seemed scarcely in place in our chief temple of lyric art. Signor Scolara, disguised in female garb, sang a buffo scene by Donizetti, in which he imitated the sounds of the different instruments of the orchestra. Capoul and Maurel—the fastidious tenor and the elegant baritone—appeared as low comedians, and in the most dilapidated and shabby of garments personated the two imposters of Offenbach’s ‘Deux Aveugles.’ The farce was chiefly spoken, though relieved by a few songs and duets. In it the two renowned opera singers proved that if they were to lose the art of singing they could easily secure engagements as comic actors on the French stage. The audience, by the way, seemed much delighted with this frolic of the two favorite artists.”
 
5)
Review: New York Herald, 11 March 1874, 7.
“Such an excellent and thoroughly enjoyable performance as that of last evening, on the occasion of the benefit of the eminent barytone, M. Maurel, deserved a better house. The audience was by no means commensurate in numbers to the merits of the entertainment. The curtain first rose on the grand scene of the third act of ‘Ernani,’ with Mlle. Torriani as Elvira, Capoul as Ernani and Maurel as Carlo Quinto. M. Maurel’s noble voice seemed to have gained additional power, sonority and inspiration in the grand theme with which this act closes, and he was efficiently supported by the other two artists. A redemand was the unanimous endorsement of the excellence of the performance by the audience.
The performance concluded with a most humorous scene by that operatic Puck, Offenbach, called ‘Les Deux Aveugles’ (‘The Two Blind Men’), in which MM. Capoul and Maurel took part. It can only be described as uproariously funny, and in the hands of two such artists it lost nothing of its irresistible comic power. The last time it was given here, we believe, was at the Théâtre Français, by two members of Bateman’s opéra comique company. The two mendicant humbugs who solicit alms and endeavor to soften the hearts of the obdurate passers by by outrageous ditties, with trombone and guitar accompaniment, were represented, attired and acted by Capoul and Maurel with inimitable skill. Such a performance, taken in general, was worthy of a crowded house.”
6)
Review: New York Sun, 12 March 1874, 2.
“Very few artists have risen so quickly into public esteem as M. Victor Maurel, whose benefit occurred on Tuesday evening at the Academy.
The programme was a varied and interesting one, and the house was well filled with enthusiastic friends of the popular beneficiary. He was fortunate in having the assistance of such artists as Madame Nilsson, Mlle. Toriani, M. Capoul and M. Wieniawski. The entertainment was partly concert, partly opera. In the former, Madame Nilsson sang, with superb voice and great effect, an aria from Rossini’s ‘Otello,’ and in response to the inevitable encore, gave, with M. Wieniawski’s violin obbligato, Gounod’s ‘Ave Maria,’ which she sang not at all religiously, but still with a breadth and power that took the audience by storm.
The most salient part of the programme was the concluding piece, a bit of burlesque to which Offenbach furnished the music, and some admirable wit the words entitled ‘Les Deux Aveugles.’ Both Maurel and Capoul have been rather successful in gaining the admiration of the young ladies who attend the opera; but certainly it would have been an extinguisher to the enthusiasm of the most ardent of their admirers, for their make-up was that of two of the dirtiest and most disreputable villains that could be conceived of. The piece was admirably done by them, with a breadth of humor and low comedy ability that we had not supposed either of them to possess.”
7)
Announcement: New-York Times, 22 March 1874, 5.

Baritone’s departure for London on the steamer Pereire.